Showing posts with label Bob Cousy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bob Cousy. Show all posts

Saturday, October 16, 2021

Top 100 NBA Players: #15 - Bob Cousy


Bob Cousy

Teams

Boston Celtics - 1950-63

Cincinnati Royals - 1969-70


Playoffs

Appearances - 13 (1951,1952,1953,1954,1955,1956,1957,1958,1959,1960,1961,1962,1963)

Conference Finals - 10 (1953,1954,1955,1957,1958,1959,1960,1961,1962,1963)

NBA Finals - 7 (1957,1958,1959,1960,1961,1962,1963)

Championships - 6 (1957,1959,1960,1961,1962,1963)


Awards and Honors

MVP - 1 (1953,1955,1957,1959)

Finals MVP - 0 (1957,1959)

All-NBA First Team - 10 (1952,1953,1954,1955,1956,1957,1958,1959,1960,1961)

All-NBA Second Team - 2 (1951,1961,1962,1963)

Hall of Fame - 1971

*(actual in bold, deserved in italics)


All-Time Ranks

Total Assists - #20

Assists Per Game - #21


League Leads

Total Assists (#1-1953,1954,1955,1956,1957,1958,1960, #2-1952, #3-1961,1962,1963, #4-1951)

Assists Per Game (#1-1953,1954,1955,1956,1957,1958,1959,1960, #2-1952, #3-1961,1962,1963, #4-1951)

Total Points (#2-1954, #3-1952,1953,1955)

Points Per Game (#2-1954,1955, #3-1952, #4-1953)

Free Throw Percentage (#3-1958, #4-1956,1959)


After averaging 19.4 points per game as a senior at Holy Cross in Worcester, Massachusetts, Bob Cousy was drafted by the Tri-Cities Blackhawks with the #3 overall pick in the NBA Draft. He did not to play for them, so they released his rights, which were then picked up by the Chicago Stags, who then folded before he was able to play for them. He was then awarded to the Boston Celtics in a dispersal draft.

As a rookie, Cousy was already a solid player, averaging 15.6 points, 6.9 rebounds, and 4.9 assists per game, and was able to lead the Celtics to the playoffs for just the second time in their history, but they lost in the first round to the Knicks. The next season he averaged 21.7 points per game and was named to the All-NBA First Team for the first of 10 straight seasons, but the Celtics lost to the Knicks in the first round again. 

In his third season, he led the league in assists with 7.7 per game, the first of 8 straight seasons winning that crown, and also averaged 19.8 points and 6.3 rebounds. The MVP award did not exist yet, but Cousy would have been my choice to win it that year, as the assist leader and #3 in scoring in the league. He also got them through the first round of the playoffs, scoring 50 points in a 4-overtime final game of the series, before losing to the Knicks in the Conference Finals.

His averages dipped slightly the next year to 19.2 points and 7.2 assists, but that was still good enough for the assist title, but Syracuse beat the Celtics in the Conference Finals. In 1955, he averaged 21.2 points, #2 in the league, 6.0 rebounds, and 7.8 assists per game, which would have earned him his second MVP if the award existed, but Syracuse stopped them in the Conference Finals again.

After a first-round playoff exit in 1956, the Celtics added Tom Heinsohn and Bill Russell in the offseason. This gave the Celtics the inside presence they needed, and Cousy won the MVP, which had been created the year before, with averages of 20.6 points and 7.5 assists. In the playoffs, the Celtics were finally able to reach their first-ever NBA Finals, where they beat the Hawks in 7 games, behind Cousy's averages of 20.7 points and 9.1 assists, which would have earned him a Finals MVP if it had existed.

Boston returned to the Finals the next year for a rematch with the Hawks, but after Russell went down with a foot injury in Game 3, the Celtics fell in 6 games, ending their bid for a repeat, but it would be the last time Cousy lost a playoff series.

Cousy had another great year in 1958-59, averaging 20.0 points, 5.5 rebounds, and 8.6 assists, but lost the MVP to Bob Pettit. During that season, Cousy set a record that would last for years when he recorded 28 assists in a game, and the 19 assists he had in a half in that game is still a record today. The Celtics advanced to the Finals for the third straight year, and Cousy averaged 16.8 points and 12.8 assists in a 4-game sweep of the Lakers, which would have been good enough for a second Finals MVP.

The next year he led the league in assists for the 8th and final time, with a career high 9.5 per game, and they faced the Hawks in the Finals for the 3rd time in 4 years, winning the series in 7 games. By this point, Russell had taken over as the team's superstar, though Cousy was still the team's second-best player and a big part of the reason they won.

Cousy played 3 more years with the Celtics, with his scoring and assist averages starting to slip a bit each year, finishing #3 in the league in assists each season. He played better in the playoffs than the regular season each year, and was able to earn 3 more championships, bringing his career total to 6, before retiring at the end of the 1963 Finals. He made a brief comeback 7 years later as a player-coach for Cincinnati, scoring 5 points in 7 total games.

Cousy is well-known for leading the league in assists, doing it in 8 straight seasons, a record that stood for decades before John Stockton did it for 9. He was the first flashy player in the league, well-known for dribbling behind the back and passing on the run, and he was nicknamed the "Houdini of the Hardwood" for his playing style. He won an MVP and should have won a couple more, and was the best player on the first 2 championships of the Celtics dynasty, and is one of the greatest to ever play the game.




Saturday, September 17, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #11 - Bill Russell


Bill Russell

Bill Russell is usually on the short list of players considered to be the best of all time, and most experts rank him among the top 4 players of all time, but my formula ranks him significantly lower. I mean no disrespect in ranking him this low, but when you look at the facts, it just makes sense.

As I described earlier in my biography of Oscar Robertson, Russell played in an era of inflated statistics, so when you look at his career averages of 15.1 points and 22.5 rebounds per game, you must remember that those numbers are much higher due to the faster pace of the game and the lower shooting percentages that produced more available rebounds. If you adjust his stats for deflation to today's rates, his career numbers would be 12.1 points and 13.3 rebounds per game. That would still place him among the greatest rebounders of all time, but makes him quite mediocre offensively.

In order to be considered one of the all-time greatest players, a player needs to be exceptional in multiple facets of the game, whether it is offense, defense, longevity, or winning. Russell was a subpar offensive player, shooting just 44% from the field and 56% from the line for his career, and his longevity was decent at 13 seasons. Russell is, however, one of the game's greatest defensive players, and if blocked shots had been counted during his career, it may have been possible to rank him higher, but there is no way to prove what he did during those years.

When it comes to winning, there was no one better. In his 13 seasons in the NBA, he won 11 NBA Championships. The two times he didn't when occurred when he was injured and unable to compete or worn out from his first season as both a player and a coach. Of those 11 title teams, Russell was the best player on 8, the famous 8 consecutive titles that covered most of the 1960's. During their first title run the Celtics were still Bob Cousy's team, and by the time they won their final two titles they had become John Havlicek's team. The Finals MVP award did not exist during his career, but if it had, he would have deserved to win it eight times, and in recognition of that the NBA renamed the Finals MVP award after him in 2009.

There are only 4 players in history who can claim they were the best player on at least 3 consecutive title teams: George Mikan, Bill Russell, Michael Jordan, and Shaquille O'Neal. There are only a few others who can even claim they were the best on 3 total, such as Bird, Magic, Duncan, Havlicek, and LeBron. Besides those titles in the NBA, he also won a gold medal in the 1956 Olympics, as well as 2 national championships in his final two years at the University of San Francisco. So despite his shortcomings on the offensive side of the ball and his average longevity, Russell will always have a place among the game's greats.

Monday, September 12, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #16 - George Mikan


George Mikan

George Mikan is probably the most difficult player to place within any countdown of the greatest players of all time, but any list that doesn't contain him is absolutely flawed. Mikan dominated the league in an era where the game was played very differently, and he is the reason for many rule changes that we recognize today as integral parts of the game.

In Mikan's first three seasons, he led the NBA in scoring, scoring over 27 points per game over 3 straight seasons, while only a couple of other players were even reaching the 20-point plateau. The MVP award did not exist in his day, but if it did, his name would have been permanently etched on it. Here are his stats from his first three seasons compared to those of the second-best players in each of those seasons:

Mikan (1949) - 28.3 pts, 3.6 ast, .416 FG%, .772 FT%
Fulks (1949) - 26.0 pts, 1.2 ast, .313 FG%, .787 FT%

Mikan (1950) - 27.4 pts, 2.9 ast, .407 FG%, .779 FT%
Groza (1950) - 23.4 pts, 2.5 ast, .478 FG%, .729 FT%

Mikan (1951) - 28.4 pts, 14.1 reb, 3.1 ast, .428 FG%, .803 FT%
Schayes (1951) - 17.0 pts, 16.4 reb, 3.8 ast, .357 FG%, .752 FT%

Fulks shot free throws better than Mikan, Groza shot field goals better, and Schayes was better on the boards, but Mikan was the top player in the NBA in all of those seasons with no doubt. He would have won all 3 MVP awards easily, and would have won championships in all three seasons if he hadn't broken his leg during the playoffs. Instead of sitting out with such a major injury, he had the team doctor tape it up with a plate on each side and played through it, getting his team to the conference finals anyway. There also was no Finals MVP award yet at that point, but he would have won two in those first two seasons.

After the 1951 season, the league made a rule change to prevent Mikan from being so dominant, and that rule change was widening the three-second lane from 6 feet to twelve feet, which is much closer to what we recognize today. Mikan's scoring average and shooting percentage dropped significantly due to this change, so he focused more on rebounding, and in the next two seasons he led the league in that category instead. Here are his stats over the next two seasons, both of which would have been MVP seasons for him as well:

Mikan (1952) - 23.8 pts, 13.5 reb, 3.0 ast, .385 FG%, .780 FT%
Cousy (1952) - 21.7 pts, 6.4 reb, 6.7 ast, .369 FG%, .808 FT%

Mikan (1953) - 20.6 pts, 14.4 reb, 2.9 ast, .399 FG%, .780 FT%
Cousy (1953) - 19.8 pts, 6.3 reb, 7.7 ast, .352 FG%, .816 FT%

Mikan was still the best player in the league, but the #2 player was no longer a center or power forward, he was a point guard. The rule change had made it possible for a player to dominate the game from any position, making Mikan's grip on the best player title less sure. He did lead the Lakers to two more championships in those seasons, and would have added two more Finals MVP's to his collection.

1954 was the season in which Cousy finally displaced Mikan as the league's premier player, and Mikan knew that the end was near. Even though he wasn't the best player anymore, he still led the Lakers to one more title, giving him 5 in six seasons. He retired after the playoffs, possibly because of the aforementioned reason, or possibly to spend more time with his family, which is the reason he gave. Most likely, it was because of another rule that was implemented that summer: the 24-second shot clock. That rule prevented the Lakers from standing around waiting for Mikan to get into position before tossing him the ball for an easy inside shot. His lack of speed would have been his downfall, and he proved it by attempting a comeback a year later, averaging only 10 points and 8 rebounds during half a season of action.

Though Mikan's career was extremely short (only 7 seasons) he was the dominant player of his era, and if the awards had been thought of earlier, Mikan's trophy case would include 5 Regular Season and 5 Finals MVP awards. Also, he is the one we can thank for many of the rules today that keep the game interesting and competitive, so there is no way that he can be left out of the top section of these rankings.

Thursday, September 8, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #21 - John Havlicek


John Havlicek

When the greatest players in Celtics history are named, most people would list Larry Bird, Bill Russell, and Bob Cousy, but John Havlicek was the player who kept the Celtics relevant after Russell's retirement and was a member of both championship teams between the Russell and Bird years.

When Havlicek came into the league, he joined the perennial champion Boston Celtics, and although he was only a role player for the first few years, he was a contributor to teams that continued to win titles throughout the 60's. He averaged 14.3 points as a rookie, which turned out to be the lowest he would average in his 16-year career. He ended his career with the third-most championships of any player, with 8, behind only Bill Russell and Sam Jones, and 38 years later he still hasn't been passed on that list.

Starting in 1966-67, Havlicek started a run of 9 straight seasons as one of the 10 best players in the NBA, hitting his peak in 1970-71 and 1971-72, when he averaged 28.2 points, 8.6 rebounds, and 7.5 assists over two seasons as he became the face of the Celtics. Unfortunately, his personal peak fell right in between the years of Celtic dominance, but he did have a huge part on several champs.

In his second, third, and fourth seasons, Havlicek worked his way up the ladder toward becoming the best player in Boston, passing Bob Cousy, then Tom Heinsohn, then Sam Jones, then finally Bill Russell as the best player on the title team. While it may seem almost sacrilegious to say that Havlicek ever surpassed Russell, he was actually the best player on Russell's final two title teams, in 1968 and 1969. Here are their stats from those two playoffs:

Havlicek (1968) - 25.9 pts, 8.6 reb, 7.5 ast, .452 FG%, .828 FT%
Russell (1968) - 14.4 pts, 22.8 reb, 5.2 ast, .409 FG%, .585 FT%

Havlicek (1969) - 25.4 pts, 9.9 reb, 5.6 ast, .445 FG%, .855 FT%
Russell (1969) - 10.8 pts, 20.5 reb, 5.4 ast, .423 FG%, .506 FT%

Russell was obviously the better rebounder, one of the two best of all time, but Havlicek was a much better scorer, shooter, and, most importantly, free throw shooter. 1968 happened to be the final season that the Finals MVP award didn't exist, and 1969 was the only season that a player from the losing team won the award, when Jerry West averaged over 40 points per game in the Finals and over 30 points per game over the entire playoffs. If you believe that the best player from the winning team should get the Finals MVP, then Havlicek should have won both of these. As it turns out, he did win one a few years later, when he led a completely new Boston team to the title. Look at his stats from those playoffs:

Havlicek (1974) - 27.1 pts, 6.4 reb, 6.0 ast, .484 FG%, .881 FT%

A quick glance will tell you that he hadn't dropped off at all, and had probably gained a step, despite the fact that he was 33 years old by this time. He had become a more efficient shooter and scorer while maintaining impressive averages in rebounds and assists. That was also the first season in which defensive stats were recorded, and he managed to average 1.3 steals per game during that playoff run as well.

Monday, September 5, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #25 - Bob Pettit


Bob Pettit

Of the top 25 players of all time, Bob Pettit is probably the least remembered. Part of that has to do with him retiring in 1965, long before most of today's sports fans were following the sport. It also has a lot to do with the fact that he played the majority of his career in Saint Louis, a city that no longer has an NBA team, and with no fan base left to celebrate him, he has been largely forgotten.

Here are some good reason to remember Pettit. For the 4 seasons before Wilt Chamberlain came into the league, Pettit was the best player in the league, winning 2 MVP's and playing in 2 NBA Finals. The MVP award was created in 1956, and Pettit was the first to ever win the award, in just his second year as a pro. Here are his stats from that season, compared with those of Bob Cousy, his nearest competitor:

Pettit - 25.7 pts, 16.2 reb, 2.6 ast, .429 FG%, .736 FT%
Cousy - 18.8 pts, 6.8 reb, 8.9 ast, .360 FG%, .844 FT%

Pettit was the league's leading scorer that year, while Cousy led the league in assists. Cousy was better at the guard stats, and Pettit at the big man stats, so the scoring title made him the better player. In 1957 and 1958, the MVP's were won by Cousy and Russell, but Pettit had a legitimate argument for both. Here are their statistical comparisons from those seasons:

Pettit (1957) - 24.7 pts, 14.6 reb, 1.9 ast, .415 FG%, .773 FT%
Cousy (1957) - 20.6 pts, 4.8 reb, 7.5 ast, .378 FG%, .821 FT%

Pettit (1958) - 24.6 pts, 17.4 reb, 2.2 ast, .410 FG%, .749 FT%
Russell (1958) - 16.6 pts, 22.7 reb, 2.9 ast, .442 FG%, .519 FT%

Pettit and Cousy were both slightly down in 1957, but since Pettit was already the better player before, I believe he was still the better player. The following season it was a little easier to make the comparison, since he and Russell were both big men, and while Russell was a little better from the field and on the boards, Pettit was much better from the line and at scoring in general.

There are only two retired players in NBA history to play at least 3 seasons and score at least 20 points per game in every season they played. Michael Jordan is one of them. The other is Bob Pettit. Pettit led the league in scoring twice, but after Wilt arrived he never led the league again. That didn't prevent him from becoming the first player ever to reach 20,000 points, and he was also the league's all-time leading scorer when he retired.

Another thing that sets Pettit apart and makes him memorable is that he played one of the greatest games in NBA Finals history, and it happened to come in the game in which Bill Russell lost his only NBA Finals. Pettit scored what was then a playoff record 50 points in Game 6, and they needed every one of them to beat Boston 110-109.

Besides that Finals victory, Pettit and the Hawks also made three other appearances in the Finals, losing to the Celtics each time. Pettit was easily the best player on each of those teams, and also on two other teams that lost in the Conference Finals. He was ranked among the top 5 players in the entire league for each of his first 10 season, falling out in season 11 due to an injury that caused him to retire.

Saturday, August 6, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #59 - Bill Sharman


Bill Sharman

Bill Sharman was probably the first great shooting guard in NBA history. During his era, guards never shot over 40% from the field, but Sharman did it 9 straight times. He was also the first great free throw shooter, never shooting worse than .844 from the line, which included 7 seasons leading the league, and his .932 in 1959 stood as the best in history for nearly 20 years.

Sharman also won 4 NBA titles as a starter for the Boston Celtics at the end of his career. He was never the best player on those title teams, but he was the second-best player on the 1957 champs, then third or 4th best on the other 3 winners as Bill Russell and Tom Heinsohn emerged as stars. Here are his, Russell's, and Cousy's stats from that 1957 title run:

Sharman - 21.1 pts, 3.5 reb, 2.9 ast, .381 FG%, .953 FT%
Russell - 13.9 pts, 24.4 reb, 3.2 ast, .365 FG%, .508 FT%
Cousy - 20.2 pts, 6.1 reb, 9.3 ast, .324 FG%, .747 FT%

You can see that Sharman provided the scoring and shooting while Russell had the muscle and Cousy distributed the ball. What's most interesting is that Sharman had a better field goal percentage than his center, and he was only 6-1. He was one of the 5 best regular season players 3 times, including his peak years of 1956-57 and 1957-58, where he and Bob Cousy were the best duo in the league. Look at their overall stats from those two years:

Sharman - 21.7 pts, 4.5 reb, 3.1 ast, .420 FG%, .900 FT%
Cousy - 19.3 pts, 4.9 reb, 7.3 ast, .365 FG%, .833 FT%

Both were great scorers and rebounders for their position and era, both got a lot of assists in a time in which they were tougher to get, and both could hit free throws with the best of them. Putting these two together in the backcourt at that time would be similar to putting Michael Jordan and Magic Johnson together in the late 1980's. Can you imagine losing with that combination. It's no wonder they won 4 titles in 5 years.

Friday, July 15, 2016

Top 100 NBA Players: #83 - John Stockton


John Stockton

I realize that many may call it blasphemy to put Stockton this low in the all-time rankings, especially with all of the individual achievements in his career, and it hurts me to put him here too, because I have the utmost respect for him as a player and as a human being, but the fact is that he wasn't as good as many have made him out to be.

A few people will try to claim that his assist record should be discounted because assists were easier to get in his era than they were earlier days of the league, and will often compare his numbers to those of Bob Cousy to make their point, but the truth is that the average number of assists per game changed very little from 1951 through today. Assists did reach their peak in the mid-1980's, but the difference wasn't that huge. In 1956, when Cousy led the league with 8.9 assists per game, the average team got 24.3 per game, and when Stockton led the league with 14.2 assists per game in 1991, the team average league-wide was 24.7. The only time in which assists were truly hard to get was the first four seasons of the NBA, in which the average for a team was still in the single digits.

The obvious question here is, "What caused the difference between Cousy and Stockton if assists were just as easy to get back then?" The real difference is specialization. Before the 1980's, most teams did not differentiate a point guard from a shooting guard. Whichever one got the ball took it up the court, and was more likely to record an assist. That is a small part of the reason that Stockton is ranked this low, but only a part.

Let's look for a moment at Stockton's other major achievement, which is his all-time record for steals. This one is especially misleading, because steals, unlike assists, have only been recorded for the past 43 years, meaning that there is no way to know whether he really has the most overall steals. If Jordan hadn't retired for five seasons in the prime of his career, he could easily have passed Stockton here. This record was also helped by the fact that he has played in the third-most games all-time, and is the only guard near the top of that list. He was a good defensive player and led the league in steals twice, but this record doesn't help his all-time standing quite as much.

Another thing holding Stockton back was the lack of postseason success. He played in two NBA Finals late in his career, and he was still the #2 player on the Jazz, just as he had been for over a decade, but that seems to eclipse his previous playoff failings in the eyes of many. The truth is that in his 19 seasons, the Jazz made the playoffs every single season, but lost in the first round 9 times, and in the second round 5 more times. That leaves 3 Western Conference Finals seasons and the two trips to the Finals, where they lost to Michael Jordan and the Bulls. How can someone be considered one of the greatest of all time if he was never the best player on his own team?

To recap, I want to emphasize that I love John Stockton. I loved the way he played, and especially the way he showed up every night. In 17 different seasons he never missed a single game. He played his entire career with one team, showing great loyalty to the Utah team that took a chance on the small-school boy. The Jazz made the playoffs every single season that he was on the roster. I just can't overlook the fact that he wasn't ever a superstar. He only ranked among the top 15 players in the league once, and was never his team's best player. He rarely saw playoff success, and the majority of it came after he had started to decline as a player. He was very good at the things he was supposed to do, and not so great at the things he wasn't expected to do. Overall, he exceeded a lot of expectations, but he is not one of the top 75 players of all time. Sorry.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Top 100 NBA Players: #13


Elgin Baylor

(Kalb: #13, Simmons: #14, BBR: #20)

If you don't know who Elgin Baylor is, you're not alone. He is easily the least recognizable or remembered player among the top 20, and a big part of that is the era in which he played. Games were not televised, so the only chance fans got to see him was live at the game. Baylor is also one of only three players remaining on this list that never won a championship, but it isn't for lack of trying.

Elgin played 12 full seasons in the NBA, with 8 of those seasons ending in the NBA Finals, 7 against the Boston Celtics. Baylor was the best player on 4 of those teams, #2 on two others, and still the third best player on the team in his 12th season in the NBA. The players who ranked ahead of him on those teams were Jerry West and Wilt Chamberlain, so it's not like he was taking a back seat to a flash in the pan. There was one other season in which the Lakers lost to Boston in the Finals with Baylor sitting on the bench with a knee injury.

Baylor was not only a good player on a good team for all those years, he was one of the top 10 players in the league for 10 of his 12 full seasons. As a rookie, he was already the second-best player in the NBA, behind only Bob Pettit, and he only got better from there. Even though he was only 6-5, he averaged 24.9 points, 15.0 rebounds, and 4.1 assists that season, and he was known as the first player to play above the rim, showing hang time that had never been seen before.

His fourth season was 1961-62, the season of incomprehensible stats, and Baylor's numbers that season were yet another example. He had been called to active military duty during the season, so he was only able to play on weekends, but he still managed to participate in 48 games and average 38.3 points, 18.6 rebounds, and 4.6 assists, all during his weekend breaks from the military.

Baylor averaged over 24 points and 10 rebounds for 11 seasons, making him the greatest scorer/rebounder under 6-6 in league history, narrowly edging out Charles Barkley, another player who was never able to win a title. Baylor, however, may have allowed the Lakers to win a title. In 1971-72, he was returning from a major knee injury that had cost him almost a full season, and after nine games he felt that he was holding back a team that could be historically good, so he retired, and the very next game was the beginning of Los Angeles' record 33-game winning streak, and the Lakers also went on to win the title that season. There are not many players who would step aside in order to allow their team to reach their full potential, let alone one as great as Baylor, so that gesture was huge.


While Baylor did not win the championships that Russell did, mostly because of Russell, he did make it to the Finals 8 times, not far behind Russell's 12, and their careers covered almost the exactly same timeframe. Russell was a slightly better rebounder, but he was also at least 6 inches taller, so that's to be expected, but Baylor's worst scoring season was still 6 points per game better than Russell's best. What really puts Baylor ahead here is that he did more with less, since he took the Lakers to all those Finals with only one other star for the majority of his career, while Russell always had at least two, whether it was Cousy, Jones, or Havlicek helping him out.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Top 100 NBA Players: #14


Bill Russell

(Kalb: #4, Simmons: #2, BBR: #4)

Bill Russell is usually on the short list of players considered to be the best of all time, and you can see that each of the other rankings I have referenced above had him among the top 4 players of all time, but I've chosen to rank him significantly lower. I mean no disrespect in ranking him this low, but when you look at the facts, it just makes sense.

As I described earlier in my biography of Oscar Robertson, Russell played in an era of inflated statistics, so when you look at his career averages of 15.1 points and 22.5 rebounds per game, you must remember that those numbers are much higher due to the faster pace of the game and the lower shooting percentages that produced more available rebounds. If you adjust his stats for deflation to today's rates, his career numbers would be 12.1 points and 13.3 rebounds per game. That would still place him among the greatest rebounders of all time, but makes him quite average offensively.

In order to be considered one of the all-time greatest players, a player needs to be exceptional in multiple facets of the game, whether it is offense, defense, longevity, or winning. Russell was a subpar offensive player, shooting just 44% from the field and 56% from the line for his career, and his longevity was just average at 13 seasons. Russell is, however, one of the game's greatest defensive players, and if blocked shots had been counted during his career, it may have been possible to rank him higher, but there is no way to prove what he did during those years.

When it comes to winning, there was no one better. In his 13 seasons in the NBA, he won 11 NBA Championships. The two times he didn't when occurred when he was injured and unable to compete or worn out from his first season as both a player and a coach. Of those 11 title teams, Russell was the best player on 8, the famous 8 consecutive titles that covered most of the 1960's. During their first title run the Celtics were still Bob Cousy's team, and by the time they won their final two titles they had become John Havlicek's team. The Finals MVP award did not exist during his career, but if it had, he would have deserved to win it eight times, and in recognition of that the NBA renamed the Finals MVP award after him in 2009.

There are only 4 players in history who can claim they were the best player on at least 3 consecutive title teams: George Mikan, Bill Russell, Michael Jordan, and Shaquille O'Neal. There are only a few others who can even claim they were the best on 3 total, such as Bird, Magic, Duncan, and Havlicek. Besides those titles in the NBA, he also won a gold medal in the 1956 Olympics, as well as 2 national championship in his final two years at the University of San Francisco. So despite his shortcomings on the offensive side of the ball and his average longevity, Russell will always have a place among the game's greats.


The question of Russell vs. Drexler seems almost silly, but I have already shows that Russell was slightly overrated and Drexler was vastly underrated, so when you compare the two, they're actually closer than you think. They were both very good defensive players, with the slight edge going to Russell, and Drexler's 15 seasons give him the longevity edge over Russell. Drexler was a far better offensive player than Russell, averaging over 20 points per game for the majority of his career, a number that Russell never matched in a single season. But Russell still gets the edge here for his winning ways, since Drexler's title came after he became Olajuwon's second banana, while Russell led his team to championships nearly every season.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Top 100 NBA Players: #21


Bob Pettit

(Kalb: #11, Simmons: #17, BBR: #21)

Of the top 25 players of all time, Bob Pettit is probably the least remembered. Part of that has to do with him retiring in 1965, long before most of today's sports fans were following the sport. It also has a lot to do with the fact that he played the majority of his career in Saint Louis, a city that no longer has an NBA team, and with no fan base left to celebrate him, he has been largely forgotten.

Here are some good reason to remember Pettit. For the 4 seasons before Wilt Chamberlain came into the league, Pettit was the best player in the league, winning 2 MVP's and playing in 2 NBA Finals. The MVP award was created in 1956, and Pettit was the first to ever win the award, in just his second year as a pro. Here are his stats from that season, compared with those of Bob Cousy, his nearest competitor:

Pettit - 25.7 pts, 16.2 reb, 2.6 ast, .429 FG%, .736 FT%
Cousy - 18.8 pts, 6.8 reb, 8.9 ast, .360 FG%, .844 FT%

Pettit was the league's leading scorer that year, while Cousy led the league in assists. Cousy was better at the guard stats, and Pettit at the big man stats, so the scoring title made him the better player. In 1957 and 1958, the MVP's were won by Cousy and Russell, but Pettit had a legitimate argument for both. Here are their statistical comparisons from those seasons:

Pettit (1957) - 24.7 pts, 14.6 reb, 1.9 ast, .415 FG%, .773 FT%
Cousy (1957) - 20.6 pts, 4.8 reb, 7.5 ast, .378 FG%, .821 FT%

Pettit (1958) - 24.6 pts, 17.4 reb, 2.2 ast, .410 FG%, .749 FT%
Russell (1958) - 16.6 pts, 22.7 reb, 2.9 ast, .442 FG%, .519 FT%

Pettit and Cousy were both slightly down in 1957, but since Pettit was already the better player before, I believe he was still the better player. The following season it was a little easier to make the comparison, since he and Russell were both big men, and while Russell was a little better from the field and on the boards, Pettit was much better from the line and at scoring in general.

There are only two retired players in NBA history to play at least 3 seasons and score at least 20 points per game in every season they played. Michael Jordan is one of them. The other is Bob Pettit. Pettit led the league in scoring twice, but after Wilt arrived he never led the league again. That didn't prevent him from becoming the first player ever to reach 20,000 points, and he was also the league's all-time leading scorer when he retired.

Another thing that sets Pettit apart and makes him memorable is that he played one of the greatest games in NBA Finals history, and it happened to come in the game in which Bill Russell lost his only NBA Finals. Pettit scored what was then a playoff record 50 points in Game 6, and they needed every one of them to beat Boston 110-109.

Besides that Finals victory, Pettit and the Hawks also made three other appearances in the Finals, losing to the Celtics each time. Pettit was easily the best player on each of those teams, and also on two other teams that lost in the Conference Finals. He was ranked among the top 5 players in the entire league for each of his first 10 season, falling out in season 11 due to an injury that caused him to retire.


David Robinson started off playing at a higher level than Pettit, and he also hung around longer and won one more championship than him, but he was never the best player in the NBA, which Pettit was for four seasons, and Pettit remained a superstar for much longer than Robinson. The four trips to the Finals were the final piece that pushed Pettit ahead of Robinson to a spot just outside the top 20 players of all time.

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players: #23


George Mikan

(Kalb: #19, Simmons: #36, BBR: #59)

George Mikan is probably the most difficult player to place within any countdown of the greatest players of all time, but any list that doesn't contain him is absolutely flawed. Mikan dominated the league in an era where the game was played very differently, and he is the reason for many rule changes that we recognize today as integral parts of the game.

In Mikan's first three seasons, he led the NBA in scoring, scoring over 27 points per game over 3 straight seasons, while only a couple of other players were even reaching the 20-point plateau. The MVP award did not exist in his day, but if it did, his name would have been permanently etched on it. Here are his stats from his first three seasons compared to those of the second-best players in each of those seasons:

Mikan (1949) - 28.3 pts, 3.6 ast, .416 FG%, .772 FT%
Fulks (1949) - 26.0 pts, 1.2 ast, .313 FG%, .787 FT%

Mikan (1950) - 27.4 pts, 2.9 ast, .407 FG%, .779 FT%
Groza (1950) - 23.4 pts, 2.5 ast, .478 FG%, .729 FT%

Mikan (1951) - 28.4 pts, 14.1 reb, 3.1 ast, .428 FG%, .803 FT%
Schayes (1951) - 17.0 pts, 16.4 reb, 3.8 ast, .357 FG%, .752 FT%

Fulks shot free throws better than Mikan, Groza shot field goals better, and Schayes was better on the boards, but Mikan was the top player in the NBA in all of those seasons with no doubt. He would have won all 3 MVP awards easily, and would have won championships in all three seasons if he hadn't broken his leg during the playoffs. Instead of sitting out with such a major injury, he had the team doctor tape it up with a plate on each side and played through it, getting his team to the conference finals anyway. There also was no Finals MVP award yet at that point, but he would have won two in those first two seasons.

After the 1951 season, the league made a rule change to prevent Mikan from being so dominant, and that rule change was widening the three-second lane from 6 feet to twelve feet, which is much closer to what we recognize today. Mikan's scoring average and shooting percentage dropped significantly due to this change, so he focused more on rebounding, and in the next two seasons he led the league in that category instead. Here are his stats over the next two seasons, both of which would have been MVP seasons for him as well:

Mikan (1952) - 23.8 pts, 13.5 reb, 3.0 ast, .385 FG%, .780 FT%
Cousy (1952) - 21.7 pts, 6.4 reb, 6.7 ast, .369 FG%, .808 FT%

Mikan (1953) - 20.6 pts, 14.4 reb, 2.9 ast, .399 FG%, .780 FT%
Cousy (1953) - 19.8 pts, 6.3 reb, 7.7 ast, .352 FG%, .816 FT%

Mikan was still the best player in the league, but the #2 player was no longer a center or power forward, he was a point guard. The rule change had made it possible for a player to dominate the game from any position, making Mikan's grip on the best player title less sure. He did lead the Lakers to two more championships in those seasons, and would have added two more Finals MVP's to his collection.

1954 was the season in which Cousy finally displaced Mikan as the league's premier player, and Mikan knew that the end was near. Even though he wasn't the best player anymore, he still led the Lakers to one more title, giving him 5 in six seasons. He retired after the playoffs, possibly because of the aforementioned reason, or possibly to spend more time with his family, which is the reason he gave. Most likely, it was because of another rule that was implemented that summer: the 24-second shot clock. That rule prevented the Lakers from standing around waiting for Mikan to get into position before tossing him the ball for an easy inside shot. His lack of speed would have been his downfall, and he proved it by attempting a comeback a year later, averaging only 10 points and 8 rebounds during half a season of action.

Though Mikan's career was extremely short (only 7 seasons) he was the dominant player of his era, and if the awards had been thought of earlier, Mikan's trophy case would include 5 Regular Season and 5 Finals MVP awards. Also, he is the one we can thank for many of the rules today that keep the game interesting and competitive, so there is no way that he can be left out of the top section of these rankings.


It's tough to compare Mikan to Havlicek, because the times were different and their careers were very different. Both were Finals MVP's, with Mikan deserving two more than Hondo, but Mikan was the best player in the league for 5 years, and Havlicek was never able to say that. Longevity helps Havlicek out a bit, but it's not enough to make up for how great Mikan was in those six seasons.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players - #24


John Havlicek

(Kalb: #24, Simmons: #13, BBR: #44)

When the greatest players in Celtics history are named, most people would list Larry Bird, Bill Russell, and Bob Cousy, but John Havlicek was the player who kept the Celtics relevant after Russell's retirement and was a member of both championship teams between the Russell and Bird years.

When Havlicek came into the league, he joined the perennial champion Boston Celtics, and although he was only a role player for the first few years, he was a contributor to teams that continued to win titles throughout the 60's. He averaged 14.3 points as a rookie, which turned out to be the lowest he would average in his 16-year career. He ended his career with the third-most championships of any player, behind only Bill Russell and Sam Jones, and 33 years later he still hasn't been passed on that list.

Starting in 1966-67, Havlicek started a run of 9 straight seasons as one of the 10 best players in the NBA, hitting his peak in 1970-71 and 1971-72, when he averaged 28.2 points, 8.6 rebounds, and 7.5 assists over two seasons as he became the face of the Celtics. Unfortunately, his personal peak fell right in between the years of Celtic dominance, but he did have a huge part on several champs.

In his second, third, and fourth seasons, Havlicek worked his way up the ladder toward becoming the best player in Boston, passing Bob Cousy, then Tom Heinsohn, then Sam Jones, then finally Bill Russell as the best player on the title team. While it may seem almost sacrilegious to say that Havlicek ever surpassed Russell, he was actually the best player on Russell's final two title teams, in 1968 and 1969. Here are their stats from those two playoffs:

Havlicek (1968) - 25.9 pts, 8.6 reb, 7.5 ast, .452 FG%, .828 FT%
Russell (1968) - 14.4 pts, 22.8 reb, 5.2 ast, .409 FG%, .585 FT%

Havlicek (1969) - 25.4 pts, 9.9 reb, 5.6 ast, .445 FG%, .855 FT%
Russell (1969) - 10.8 pts, 20.5 reb, 5.4 ast, .423 FG%, .506 FT%

Russell was obviously the better rebounder, one of the two best of all time, but Havlicek was a much better scorer, shooter, and, most importantly, free throw shooter. 1968 happened to be the final season that the Finals MVP award didn't exist, and 1969 was the only season that a player from the losing team won the award, when Jerry West averaged over 40 points per game in the Finals and over 30 points per game over the entire playoffs. If you believe that the best player from the winning team should get the Finals MVP, then Havlicek should have won both of these. As it turns out, he did win one a few years later, when he led a completely new Boston team to the title. Look at his stats from those playoffs:

Havlicek (1974) - 27.1 pts, 6.4 reb, 6.0 ast, .484 FG%, .881 FT%

A quick glance will tell you that he hadn't dropped off at all, and had probably gained a step, despite the fact that he was 33 years old by this time. He had become a more efficient shooter and scorer while maintaining impressive averages in rebounds and assists. That was also the first season in which defensive stats were recorded, and he managed to average 1.3 steals per game during that playoff run as well.


Havlicek and Erving had similar career peaks in both level and length, with Havlicek reaching it a little bit later as he grew up behind other superstar players, unlike Erving, who was thrust into a starring role immediately. Erving single-handedly led his team to the Conference Finals and Finals numerous times, but there's no way his playoff accomplishments can stack up with Havlicek's, who was the best player on three champions and a top-4 player on three others. The fact that Hondo was consistently able to get one step further than Erving in the playoffs is what separates these two players among the all-time greats.

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players: #35


Gary Payton

(Kalb: #36, Simmons: #40, BBR: #36)

Gary Payton may have been the best two-way point guard in the history of the league, getting it done consistently on both ends of the floor for more than a decade, and he played on some pretty good teams, missing the playoffs just twice in his 17-year career.

In 1995-96, Michael Jordan had just returned from his first retirement, and the Bulls had set an NBA record with 72 wins in the regular season, and then they walked right through the first three rounds of the playoffs with an 11-1 record, giving them an overall record of 83-11 up to that point. It may not seem like much, but the Sonics took two games from the Bulls in the Finals, which was quite an accomplishment considering that Chicago had only lost about once every three weeks during the previous 7 months. Payton was the star of that team, and probably would have won a title in any other season.

Payton's teammate, Shawn Kemp, started to go downhill after that season, leaving Payton without a teammate to help him return to the Finals. Over the next two years Seattle lost in the second round, but Payton was still putting up great numbers, which are below:

Payton - 23.9 pts, 4.5 reb, 7.9 ast, 2.0 stl, .438 FG%, .352 3P%, .874 FT%

He did eventually get back to the NBA Finals twice, once in 2004 with the Los Angeles Lakers, where he was just an average starter, then again with Miami in 2006, when he was no longer a relevant player, but still earned himself a championship ring in his 16th season.

As I mentioned above, Payton was more than just a great offensive player, he was also one of the top defensive point guards of all time. He led the league in steals once, in 1996, the same year he was named Defensive Player of the Year. He averaged over 2 steals per game 8 times, and still ranks #4 all time in total steals. In addition, he was named to the All-Defensive First Team 9 straight times, meaning that he was considered the best defensive point guard in the league for almost an entire decade.


Payton, like Cousy, was the best guard in the league at one point, but Payton did it when there was a lot more competition, and his 2000 season was amazing, with 24.2 points, 6.5 rebounds, 8.9 assists, and 1.9 steals per game. Cousy had more playoff success, but he was only the top player on a Finalist twice, just once more than Payton. Payton's peak was higher, and he lasted a couple years longer than Cousy, plus he played in an era when there was more competition for the top spot, so the guy who was undeniably great on both ends gets the slight edge.

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players: #36


Bob Cousy

(Kalb: #10, Simmons: #21, BBR: #42)

Bob Cousy was one of the greatest guards in the early days of the NBA, a man who held the record for most consecutive seasons leading the league in assists for over 30 years, and a proven winner who needs to use both hands in order to wear all of his championship rings.

Many people try to say that Cousy would have had more assists in today's NBA, where assists are supposedly easier to come by, but I showed in my profile on John Stockton (#60) that this was not true. The average assists per team per game has been largely unchanged over the past 60 years, with the only dry period for assists coming in the league's first 5 seasons. The fact is that the average in 1953, Cousy's first season leading the league in assists, was 21.1 per game, while today that average has skyrocketed to 21.5.

The real reason that Cousy did not get more assists during all those seasons he was leading the league is that there was no position called point guard back then, just guards. Because of this, there was no designated ballhandler on any certain team, which makes it even more impressive that Cousy led the league for 8 straight seasons.

Another thing that makes Cousy one of the greats is that he was the best player in the entire league for two seasons early in his career. In 1954 and 1955, before the MVP award had been created, Cousy was arguably the league's elite star, with Neil Johnston as his nearest competitor. Here are their stats from those two seasons:

Cousy (1954) - 19.2 pts, 5.5 reb, 7.2 ast, .385 FG%, .787 FT%, 42-30 record
Johnston (1954) - 24.4 pts, 11.1 reb, 2.8 ast, .449 FG%, .747 FT%, 29-43 record

Cousy (1955) - 21.2 pts, 6.0 reb, 7.8 ast, .397 FG%, .807 FT%, 36-36 record
Johnston (1955) - 22.7 pts, 15.1 reb, 3.0 ast, .440 FG%, .766 FT%, 33-39 record

Both players were great scorers for the time (ranked #1 and #2 in both seasons), and both were great at their areas of specialty (assists for Cousy and rebounds for Johnston), but Cousy was also a very good rebounder, while Johnston was not known for passing the ball much. Cousy's teams were also much better then Johnston's and made the playoffs both years, something Johnston's Warriors teams didn't.

Some people will say that Cousy won all those championships because of Bill Russell, but the truth is that without Cousy, they may not have won the first four of those titles. In fact, during Russell's rookie season of 1956-57, Cousy was still the best player on the Celtics' title team, and he was still the best player the next year when they lost in the Finals. That's when Russell took over as the star, but Cousy was still #2 in Boston for three more seasons, and was still an important player on the next two title teams, retiring after winning his sixth title. Before Russell even arrived, Cousy had led Boston to three straight Eastern Conference Finals, so there is no doubt that he was a winner, but the combination of Russell and Cousy was what made them unstoppable.


Cousy and Worthy were actually quite similar, both being known as the sidekick on great championship dynasties. Both played in at least 6 NBA Finals, with Cousy winning twice as many titles as Worthy (6 to 3). Cousy had the distinction of being the best player in the NBA for a couple years, while Worthy never approached that level. All in all, it seems quite obvious that Cousy has to be ranked higher on this list.

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players: #60


John Stockton

(Kalb: #27, Simmons: #25, BBR: #14)

I realize that many may call it blasphemy to put Stockton this low in the all-time rankings, especially with all of the individual achievements in his career, and it hurts me to put him here too, because I have the utmost respect for him as a player and as a human being, but the fact is that he wasn't as good as many have made him out to be.

A few people will try to claim that his assist record should be discounted because assists were easier to get in his era than they were earlier days of the league, and will often compare his numbers to those of Bob Cousy to make their point, but the truth is that the average number of assists per game changed very little from 1951 through today. Assists did reach their peak in the mid-1980's, but the difference wasn't that huge. In 1956, when Cousy led the league with 8.9 assists per game, the average team got 24.3 per game, and when Stockton led the league with 14.2 assists per game in 1991, the team average leaguewide was 24.7. The only time in which assists were truly hard to get was the first four seasons of the NBA, in which the average for a team was still in the single digits.

The obvious question here is, "What caused the difference between Cousy and Stockton if assists were just as easy to get back then?" The real difference is specialization. Before the 1980's, most teams did not differentiate a point guard from a shooting guard. Whichever one got the ball took it up the court, and was more likely to record an assist. That is a small part of the reason that Stockton is ranked this low, but only a part.

Let's look for a moment at Stockton's other major achievement, which is his all-time record for steals. This one is especially misleading, because steals, unlike assists, have only been recorded for the past 38 years, meaning that there is no way to know whether he really has the most overall steals. If Jordan hadn't retired for five seasons in the prime of his career, he could easily have passed Stockton here. This record was also helped by the fact that he has played in the third-most games all-time. He was a good defensive player and led the league in steals twice, but this record doesn't help his all-time standing quite as much.

Another thing holding Stockton back was the lack of postseason success. He played in two NBA Finals late in his career, and he was still the #2 player on the Jazz, just as he had been for over a decade, but that seems to eclipse his previous playoff failings in the eyes of many. The truth is that in his 19 seasons, the Jazz made the playoffs every single season, but lost in the first round 9 times, and in the second round 5 more times. That leaves 3 Western Conference Finals seasons and the two trips to the Finals, where they lost to Michael Jordan and the Bulls. In 1996, he was not as good as Jeff Hornacek, which I detailed in my article on his back at #95, and he was still Malone's sidekick on those other teams. How can someone be considered one of the greatest of all time if he was never the best player on his own team?

To recap, I want to emphasize that I love John Stockton. I loved the way he played, and especially the way he showed up every night. In 17 different seasons he never missed a single game. He played his entire career with one team, showing great loyalty to the Utah team that took a chance on the small-school boy. The Jazz made the playoffs every single season that he was on the roster. I just can't overlook the fact that he wasn't ever a superstar. He only ranked among the top 15 players in the league once, and was never his team's best player. He rarely saw playoff success, and the majority of it came after he had started to decline as a player. He was very good at the things he was supposed to do, and not so great at the things he wasn't expected to do. Overall, he exceeded a lot of expectations, but he is not one of the top 50 players of all time. Sorry.


Stockton and Parish had two of the longest careers of anybody in NBA history, and both were able to maintain a relatively even level of play for a long period of time. Parish had more playoff success, but Stockton was a bigger reason for his team's overall success. What this one really came down to was that Stockton became a relevant player a year earlier in his career than Parish did, and started his decline at the same point.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Top 100 NBA Players: #90


Bill Sharman

(Simmons: #51, BBR: #77)

Bill Sharman was probably the first great shooting guard in NBA history. During his era, guards never shot over 40% from the field, but Sharman did it 9 straight times. He was also the first great free throw shooter, never shooting worse than .844 from the line, which included 7 seasons leading the league, and his .932 in 1959 stood as the best in history for nearly 20 years.

Sharman also won 4 NBA titles as a starter for the Boston Celtics at the end of his career. He was never the best player on those title teams, but he was the second-best player on the 1957 champs, then third or 4th best on the other 3 winners as Bill Russell and Tom Heinsohn emerged as stars.

He was one of the 5 best regular season players 3 times, including his peak years of 1956-57 and 1957-58, where he and Bob Cousy were the best duo in the league. Look at their overall stats from those two years:

Sharman - 21.7 pts, 4.5 reb, 3.1 ast, .420 FG%, .900 FT%
Cousy - 19.3 pts, 4.9 reb, 7.3 ast, .365 FG%, .833 FT%

Both were great scorers and rebounders for their position and era, both got a lot of assists in a time in which they were tougher to get, and both could hit free throws with the best of them. Putting these two together in the backcourt at that time would be similar to putting Michael Jordan and Magic Johnson together in the late 1980's. Can you imagine losing with that combination. It's no wonder they won 4 titles in 5 years.


Sharman's peak years may not have been quite as good as Boozer's, but he was consistently improving his game, as you can see from the trajectory of his chart above. He was always one of the best players in the league, and when he finally fell from that position, he walked away and became one of the better coaches of all time, and he is currently one of only 3 men to be inducted into the Hall of Fame as both a player and as a coach. The reason that he falls so much lower in these rankings than in some other similar ranking systems is that he was never better than the #4 player in the league in any given season or playoff series, and in a time when there were only between 80 and 110 players in the league, that only puts him in the top 5% for his time.