Showing posts with label Kurt Warner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kurt Warner. Show all posts

Monday, August 5, 2019

Top 50 NFL Quarterbacks: #15 - Kurt Warner


Kurt Warner

Kurt Warner is probably the greatest player in league history to go undrafted, and while he only had 6 seasons as a great quarterback in the NFL, when he was at his best, there weren't many who could match his performance.

After going undrafted in 1994, he spent 4 years playing in the Arena Football League, and set tons of league records along the way. It finally earned him a contract with the Saint Louis Rams in 1998, but he spent the entire season as a 3rd-string quarterback, throwing only 11 passes all season.

Everything changed for Warner in 1999, and it was immediate. He was promoted to second string in the preseason, then became the starter before game 1 when Trent Green went down with a broken leg. He stepped in and immediately became the top passer in the league, throwing for 3 touchdowns in each of his first three games, becoming the first starter in league history to achieve that feat. He followed that up with 5 touchdowns in game 4, which extended his record.

He would finish the season with 4353 passing yards, a league-leading 41 touchdowns, and only 13 interceptions, and St. Louis finished first in the NFC with a 13-3 record while Warner won the MVP in his first full season. His dominance continued in the postseason with 391 yards and 5 touchdowns in his first ever playoff game, and after a hard-fought win over Tampa Bay in the NFC title game, he led the Rams to the Super Bowl. He threw a Super Bowl record 414 yards along with 2 touchdowns, which earned him the Super Bowl MVP in his first season as well.

He missed 5 games the next season due to a broken hand, but still led the Rams to the playoffs after throwing 3429 yards in just 11 games. He threw 365 yards and 3 touchdowns in their first playoff game, but his 3 picks lost the game for them.

He came back at full strength in 2001, throwing a career-high and league-high 4830 yards and 36 touchdowns, also tops in the league. Saint Louis finished at 14-2, best in the entire league, and Warner took home his second MVP award. They were able to make it back to the Super Bowl, where Warner threw 365 yards, the second-highest total in Super Bowl history at the time, although they lost to New England on a last-second field goal.

A broken throwing hand during the offseason was nearly the end of him. He was unable to fully grip the ball, causing him to throw 11 interceptions in just 6 starts in 2002, and to fumble 6 times in the first game of 2003. He was released after the season and signed by the New York Giants, but was replaced by Eli Manning halfway through the season.

He signed with Arizona in 2005, but was unable to hold onto the starting job for his first three seasons with the Cardinals, although he finally started to show signs of his former greatness after Matt Leinart went down with an injury early in 2007.

He took the starting job back at the beginning of 2008, and rocketed right back to the top of the league, throwing 4583 yards, #2 in the league, along with 30 touchdowns. Arizona sneaked into the playoffs with a 9-7 record, then went on to upset three straight teams with better records on their way to the first Super Bowl appearance in Cardinals history. In his third Super Bowl appearance, he threw 377 yards and 3 touchdowns, but the Cardinals lost on a last-second touchdown to Pittsburgh.

He decided to come back for one final season, and was solid during the regular season, helping Arizona to improve to 10-6, and was amazing in the wild card game, with 379 yards and 5 touchdowns as he outdueled Aaron Rodgers in the highest scoring game in playoff history 51-45. The following week he was injured making a tackle after an interception, and he was unable to finish the game as the season and his career ended.

While his career lacks the longevity of the rest of the top 20, he has a lot going for him. His 1999 season was one of the most dominant in league history, and he always played well in the playoffs. In case you missed it above, there have been 53 Super Bowls, meaning a total of 106 starting quarterbacks, and 3 of the top 6 passing games in Super Bowl history belong to Kurt Warner in his only 3 appearances. He won 2 MVP's and could have had another, and he also won a Super Bowl MVP. It may have been the oddest career of any of the greats, but he has earned this ranking.


Tuesday, August 18, 2015

Top 50 NFL Quarterbacks: #4 - Brett Favre


Brett Favre

Brett Favre is yet another quarterback whose name is all over the NFL record book, but it didn't start out looking like it would lead there. He was a second-round pick of Atlanta in 1991, but only threw 4 passes in his rookie season with the Falcons, 2 of them resulting in interceptions. He was traded to Green Bay after the season for a first-round pick.

In the fourth game of his Packers career, Favre took over the starting job from Don Majkowski, and he would not give it up for the rest of his time with the team. His first two years in Green Bay were decent, but nothing special, but he started to show his greatness in 1994, when he threw 3882 yards, 33 touchdowns, and only 14 interceptions while leading Green Bay to the playoffs for the second straight year, where they lost to Dallas in the second round.

1995 was even better, with the highest passing total of his career (4413), which led the league, along with 38 touchdowns, also #1 in the league. Green Bay won the division with an 11-5 record, and Favre won his first MVP award. In the first two round of the playoffs, he threw 5 touchdowns without a pick, but he tossed 2 in the NFC title game, which led to them losing to Dallas for the third straight season to end their run.

In 1996 he dropped his yardage total back below 4000, but threw one more touchdown while getting the Packers to the best record in the league at 13-3, earning him his second straight MVP. He didn't have amazing numbers in the playoffs, but was able to finally break through and reach the Super Bowl, where he was good. He passed for 246 yards and 2 touchdowns and ran for another, but became the only QB in history to score 3 touchdowns in a Super Bowl win without being awarded the MVP.

Three-peats of any kind are a very difficult feat in sports, but Favre accomplished one in 1997, when he led the league in touchdowns for the third straight season and was awarded his 3rd consecutive MVP, becoming the first and only player ever so honored. That amazing season was followed up with another run to the Super Bowl, where they met John Elway and the Broncos, and though Favre outplayed Elway significantly, Terrell Davis led the Broncos to victory with his 3rd touchdown late in the game.

In 1998 he led the league in passing yards for the second time, reaching 4212, but threw 23 interceptions, and his down season led to the Packers falling in the wild card round to the 49ers, marking the first time in 4 years that they failed to reach the NFC title game.

He and the Packers had a couple of down years after that, with Favre throwing a lot of interceptions and Green Bay missing the playoffs, but he made a bit of a comeback in 2001, raising his TD's back up to 32 while dropping his picks down to 15. He also led them to their first playoff victory since the Super Bowl loss, but it was just a single game, and Favre ended up throwing 6 interceptions in their second round loss to Kurt Warner and the Rams.

He remained a solid quarterback on a decent team for several more seasons, with nearly every season ending with speculation of retirement, followed by a decision to play one more season to chase another Super Bowl. His final season in Green Bay came in 2007, when he threw 4155 yards and 28 touchdowns at age 38 and led the Packers to the NFC Championship Game for the 4th time in his career.

The Packers were desperate to move on and allow Aaron Rodgers to take over the starting job, and Favre felt that they forced him into retirement, but he quickly decided to unretire, which forced the Packers to trade him away to avoid a quarterback controversy. He was sent to the Jets for a year, where he had a pretty mediocre year, followed by another retirement, and another decision to come back.

When he came back in 2009, he joined the Minnesota Vikings, and had his best season since his 3 MVP years early in his career. He finished with 4202 yards, 33 touchdowns, and a career-low 7 picks. He led the Vikings to the playoffs, and even won a playoff game, which earned them a spot in the NFC title game, the fifth of Favre's career. The playoff win earned Favre the distinction of being the oldest quarterback ever to win a playoff game, at age 40.

He played one more season with Minnesota, but was terrible, with only 11 touchdown passes and 2509 yards, the lowest total since his rookie season, which ended with 0 yards. He finally retired for good at the end of the 2010 season after a career that spanned 20 years.

The reason Favre is this high is not due to any record-breaking seasons, like most of the other top QB's. He had three excellent MVP seasons, and 6 other seasons as one of the best in the league. He led his teams to 5 conference title games and 2 Super Bowls, coming away victorious once. What really sets him apart is the volume of his career. He is currently #1 all time in passing yards, completions, attempts, interceptions, wins, and games started, as well as consecutive starts, and was #1 in touchdowns until last season. He is also the only player in history to win 3 straight MVP's, which is pretty remarkable, so there is no doubt that he deserves to be remembered as one of the best of all time.

Sunday, August 16, 2015

In Defense of Kurt Warner

It seems that there are several people who do not agree with Kurt Warner being placed above John Elway in my all-time rankings, and I believe that I may not have adequately proven that Warner was a greater overall quarterback, so let me go a little deeper into the numbers to show why Warner belongs where I have placed him.

First of all, let's start by examining the careers of the 4 quarterbacks already included in the top 10. Each of them had a very similar length of time as an elite quarterback, with 5 years each for Young and Warner, and 6 years for Rodgers and Elway. You may think that Elway was better than that, but if you actually look at his numbers, he was only among the best in 1986, 1987, 1993, and 1996-1998. Besides those years, he was a fairly mediocre, although consistent, quarterback.

Now let's compare the best season for each against the average starter in the league for that season, the only fair way to compare players from different eras:

Rodgers (2011) - 4643 yards, 45 touchdowns, 6 interceptions
Average (2011) - 3341 yards, 21 touchdowns, 13 interceptions

His yardage was 39.0% higher than the average, touchdowns 114.3%, and interceptions far lower than the average.

Young (1998) - 4170 yards, 36 touchdowns, 12 interceptions
Average (1998) - 2647 yards, 17 touchdowns, 11 interceptions

His yardage was 57.5% higher than the average, touchdowns 111.8%, with interceptions slightly higher (9.1%) than average.

Elway (1993) - 4030 yards, 25 touchdowns, 10 interceptions
Average (1993) - 2603 yards, 14 touchdowns, 11 interceptions

His yardage was 54.8% higher than the average, touchdowns 78.6%, with interceptions slightly lower than the average.

Warner (1999) - 4353 yards, 41 touchdowns, 13 interceptions
Average (1999) - 2789 yards, 17 touchdowns, 12 interceptions

His yardage was 56.1% higher than the average, touchdowns 141.2%, and interceptions slightly higher (8.3%) than average.

If you were to rank each of these passers against each other in each of these categories, Young comes out best in yardage, Warner in touchdowns, and Rodgers in interceptions, with Elway left out. If you rank them overall based on their rank in each category, Warner comes in first due to finishing #1 in TD's, #2 in yardage, and #3 in interceptions, with Rodgers second with a #1 in picks, #2 in touchdowns, and #4 in yardage. Young comes in third with #1 in yardage but #3 in touchdowns and #4 in interceptions, and Elway comes in last due to being #2 in picks, #3 in yardage, and last in touchdowns.

When you look at the playoff successes of these 4, each was responsible for one Super Bowl victory. (John Elway's first Super Bowl win was 100% due to Terrell Davis. Elway's performance in that game was the worst ever for a winning QB.) Let's look at their stats in Super Bowl MVP games:

Rodgers (2011) - 304 yards, 3 touchdowns, 0 interceptions
Young (1995) - 325 yards, 6 touchdowns, 0 interceptions
Elway (1999) - 336 yards, 1 touchdown, 1 interception
Warner (2000) - 414 yards, 2 touchdowns, 0 interceptions

In comparing the players based on these performances, Warner and Young come out tied for first, with Young #1 in touchdowns and #3 in yards while Warner was #1 in yards and #3 in touchdowns, both without interceptions. Elway comes in last again, with the fewest touchdowns and the only interception, even with the second-most yards.

Other than their championship seasons, Rodgers has advanced to one NFC title game, Young 3 of them, Elway 4 Super Bowls (including the first win), and Warner 2 Super Bowls, showing a clear demarcation between the first two and the last. When you look at how Warner and Elway performed in the Super Bowls in which they weren't MVP, you can see that Warner was far superior to Elway in championship games.

Warner (2 games) - 742 yards, 4 touchdowns, 3 interceptions
Elway (4 games) - 792 yards, 2 touchdowns, 7 interceptions

As you can clearly see, Warner had nearly as many yards in two games as Elway had in 4, meaning he averaged nearly twice as many per game. The interceptions are nearly identical, slightly in Warner's favor as well, but the touchdowns are far apart, with Warner throwing twice as many in half as many games. Elway may have been good at getting his team to the Super Bowl, but he wasn't good once he got there.

No matter which way you look at it, Warner's career was the best of any of these quarterbacks up to this point (Rodgers could easily pass all of them in the next year or two). People tend to look back at Elway's career with rose-colored glasses due to the storybook ending, but he just wasn't quite as great as most think. Elway has the slight edge in elite regular seasons and a decent edge in deep playoff runs, but Warner has a huge edge in MVP season performance, Super Bowl MVP performance, and Super Bowl losing performance, all of which proves my point that Warner was a greater overall quarterback than John Elway.


Saturday, August 15, 2015

Top 50 NFL Quarterbacks: #7 - Kurt Warner


Kurt Warner

Kurt Warner is probably the biggest surprise of any player to be included in my top 10, especially considering that he only had 6 seasons as a great quarterback in the NFL, but when he was at his best, there weren't many who could match his performance.

Warner went undrafted in 1994, and ended up spending 4 years playing in the Arena Football League, setting tons of league records along the way. It finally earned him a contract with the Saint Louis Rams in 1998, but he spent the entire season as a 3rd-string quarterback, throwing only 11 passes all season.

Everything changed for Warner in 1999, and it was immediate. He was promoted to second string in the preseason, then became the starter before game 1 when Trent Green went down with a broken leg. He stepped in and immediately became the top passer in the league, throwing for 3 touchdowns in each of his first three games, becoming the first starter in league history to achieve that feat. He followed that up with 5 touchdowns in game 4, which extended his record.

He would finish the season with 4353 passing yards, a league-leading 41 touchdowns, and only 13 interceptions, and St. Louis finished first in the NFC with a 13-3 record while Warner won the MVP in his first full season. His dominance continued in the postseason with 391 yards and 5 touchdowns in his first ever playoff game, and after a hard-fought win over Tampa Bay in the NFC title game, he led the Rams to the Super Bowl. He threw a Super Bowl record 414 yards along with 2 touchdowns, which earned him the Super Bowl MVP in his first season as well.

He missed 5 games the next season due to a broken hand, but still led the Rams to the playoffs after throwing 3429 yards in just 11 games. He threw 365 yards and 3 touchdowns in their first playoff game, but his 3 picks lost the game for them.

He came back at full strength in 2001, throwing a career-high and league-high 4830 yards and 36 touchdowns, also tops in the league. Saint Louis finished at 14-2, best in the entire league, and Warner took home his second MVP award. They were able to make it back to the Super Bowl, where Warner threw 365 yards, the second-highest total in Super Bowl history at the time, although they lost to New England on a last-second field goal.

A broken throwing hand during the offseason was nearly the end of him. He was unable to fully grip the ball, causing him to throw 11 interceptions in just 6 starts in 2002, and to fumble 6 times in the first game of 2003. He was released after the season and signed by the New York Giants, but was replaced by Eli Manning halfway through the season.

He signed with Arizona in 2005, but was unable to hold onto the starting job for his first three seasons with the Cardinals, although he finally started to show signs of his former greatness after Matt Leinart went down with an injury early in 2007.

He took the starting job back at the beginning of 2008, and rocketed right back to the top of the league, throwing 4583 yards, #2 in the league, along with 30 touchdowns. Arizona sneaked into the playoffs with a 9-7 record, then went on to upset three straight teams with better records on their way to the first Super Bowl appearance in Cardinals history. In his third Super Bowl appearance, he threw 377 yards and 3 touchdowns, but the Cardinals lost on a last-second touchdown to Pittsburgh.

He decided to come back for one final season, and was solid during the regular season, helping Arizona to improve to 10-6, and was amazing in the wild card game, with 379 yards and 5 touchdowns as he outdueled Aaron Rodgers in the highest scoring game in playoff history 51-45. The following week he was injured making a tackle after an interception, and he was unable to finish the game as the season and his career ended.

While his career lacks the longevity of the rest of the top 10, he has a lot going for him. His 1999 season was one of the most dominant in league history, and he always came played well in the playoffs. In case you missed it above, there have been 49 Super Bowls, meaning a total of 98 starting quarterbacks, and the top 3 passing games in Super Bowl history all belong to Kurt Warner. He won 2 MVP's and could have had another, and he also won a Super Bowl MVP. It may have been the oddest career of any of the greats, but he has earned this ranking.

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

Top 50 NFL Quarterbacks: #10 - Aaron Rodgers


Aaron Rodgers

It may seem strange to see such a young quarterback this high in the rankings, but Aaron Rodgers has been one of the best quarterbacks in the league ever since the day he became a starter, which was 7 years ago, after spending 3 years backing up Brett Favre, learning from one of the best.

His first season as a starter was easily his worst, finishing with "only" 4038 yards, 28 touchdowns, and 13 interceptions. In his full seasons since, he has had fewer yards only once, and has never had fewer touchdowns or more interceptions. That was also the only season in his career in which he did not lead Green Bay to the playoffs.

In 2009, he was already the second-best QB in the entire league, throwing for 4434 yards, 30 touchdowns, and only 7 picks, and the Packers finished at 11-5. They lost in the wild card game to the Arizona Cardinals, but it wasn't because of Rodgers. He finished his first playoff start with 423 yards and 4 touchdowns, but was outplayed by Kurt Warner in a 51-45 shootout loss.

He completed his ascension to the peak in his third season, when he failed to reach 4000 passing yards for the only time in his career when healthy, but destroyed the competition in the playoffs. In the first two games combined, he threw over 540 yards and 6 touchdowns without an interception. After a rough game against Chicago that they still won 21-14, he made it to the Super Bowl and had a great game, with 304 yards and 3 touchdowns, and no interceptions for the third time in the postseason. That performance made him the Super Bowl MVP.

Right after the best postseason of his career, he came back with the best regular season of his career, and one of the greatest of all time. He threw career highs of 4643 yards and 45 touchdowns, and had only 6 interceptions all season. The team finished the season 15-1, and Rodgers was named the league's MVP, as if there could be any question after a season of that magnitude.

He was great again in 2012, with 4295 yards and 39 touchdowns, a little lower than the season before, but the season ended early again with a loss in the divisional round of the playoffs. He was on pace for another great season in 2013, but broke his collarbone and missed the final 7 games.

He came back at full strength last season, with 4381 yards and 38 touchdowns with a career-low 5 picks, and Green Bay finished at 12-4, tied for the best in the NFC. He was awarded his second NFL MVP award after the season, and he led the Pack to the NFC title game, where they lost a close one to Seattle, 28-22.

Although he has only played 6 full seasons, he has been one of the top 2 quarterbacks in the league in 5 of those seasons. He has never had fewer than 3900 yards or 28 touchdowns, and never more than 13 interceptions in a season. His career TD:INT ratio is almost 4:1, which is by far the best in history. He has set records for most yardage for a QB in their first two season and in their first 5 seasons, and has the third-highest completion percentage of any quarterback in history. Add in 2 MVP's and a Super Bowl MVP, and you have one of the greatest in history, and he still has a long career ahead of him.